HPDV4000

Differences between revisions 13 and 14
Revision 13 as of 2006-05-12 06:43:41
Size: 11542
Editor: bb-87-80-240-158
Comment:
Revision 14 as of 2006-05-12 07:44:44
Size: 11850
Editor: bb-87-80-240-158
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 62: Line 62:
|| Touchpad - Scroll down side || Yes/No* || Yes || || || Touchpad - Scroll down side || Yes/No* || Yes/No || ||
Line 112: Line 112:
12 May: NEW REGRESSION: in latest Dapper (updates to 12th May 2006) the scroll-on-side-of-touchpad feature stopped working! It was working with updates to yesterday (13th May 2006). This is after a hibernate/restart so perhaps related to hibernation.
Line 123: Line 125:
 * Works fine now in latest dapper. -JulianRockey

Current Issues

DAPPER ISSUE SUMMARY

Latest test: Dapper Beta with all updates 11 May 2006

Bluetooth: my phone could see my Dapper laptop, but the laptop couldn't see in the discoverable phone with hidd --search. No gnome frontend available.

  • There is gnome-bluetooth-manager, but it's currently lacking in functionality and doesn't do much more than just scan and display a list of pretty icons. gnome-obex or whatever it's called does allow you to receive files. -PaulSladen

  • I can experiment with frontends but my main worry is that "hidd --search" doesn't find my discoverable phone. I used to have Bluetooth working fine under SuSE so I guess linux support is available for whatever chipset it is (it's built in to the laptop - not a USB dongle). -JulianRockey

Hibernate: sometimes works but sometimes seems to freeze with a blank screen whilst hibernating

  • Does leaving the laptop a long time (eg. 5 minutes+) eventually allow it to finish and power-off normally. -PaulSladen

  • I'll play around with hibernate a bit and report on findings. -JulianRockey

Hardware details

in Breezy?

in Dapper (current development)?

Installation works?

Yes

Yes

Hardware Information

Screen & Monitors

Device

Works?

Bug #

in Breezy?

in Dapper (current development)?

Screen

Yes

Yes

Correct resolution?

Yes

Yes

Correct refresh rate?

Yes

Yes

3D Acceleration

Yes

Yes

External monitor works?

Untested

No

FILE BUG! (acpi-support)

External monitor - mirrors

Untested

Untested

External monitor - extend desktop

Untested

Untested

Power Management

Battery detected?

Yes

Yes

Hibernates?

No

Sometimes

Sleep

No

Yes

Dim monitor on battery

Yes

Yes

Blank monitor on inactivity

No

Yes

Lid Close

No

No

Cpu frequency scaling

Yes

Yes

Sound

Sound works?

Yes

Yes

Correct volume?

Yes

Yes

Hardware volume switch

Yes

Yes

Headphone jack

Yes

Yes

Mic jack

Yes

Untested

Networking

Wired NIC

Yes

Yes

Wireless NIC

Yes

Yes

PCMCIA NIC

Untested

Untested

Firewire

Untested

Untested

Bluetooth

Yes

No*

Modem

Untested

Untested

Infrared

Untested

Untested

Touchpad & Mice

Touchpad

Yes

Yes

Touchpad - Doubletap = double click

Yes

Yes

Touchpad - Scroll down side

Yes/No*

Yes/No

External mouse - USB

Yes

Yes

External mouse - Serial

Untested

Untested

Docking Station/Port Replicator

AC through replicator

Untested

Untested

USB

Untested

Untested

Serial

Untested

Untested

Parallel

Untested

Untested

External Monitor - VGA

Untested

Untested

External Monitor - DVI

Untested

Untested

Modem

Untested

Untested

NIC

Untested

Untested

PS/2

Untested

Untested

Additional Hardware

Fingerprint reader

N/A

N/A

CD/DVD drive

Yes

Untested

PCMCIA cards

Yes

Yes

Parallel Ports

Untested

Untested

Card reader(s)

No

Partial (SD cards work, MemorySticks don't work)

Function and other keys

Fn key

Operation

Keycode

Works?

Bug #

in Breezy?

in Dapper (current development)?

+ Space

Nothing

Yes

Yes

+ Esc

Nothing

Yes

Yes

+ F1

Help

0x80 0x81 0x8a

Yes

Yes

+ F2

Print

0x1d 0x19 0x99 0x9d

Yes

Yes

+ F3

Web Browser

0x80 0x81 0x96

Yes

Yes

+ F4

External display

<none>

No*

No

FILE BUG! (acpi-support)

+ F5

Sleep

0xe0 0x5f 0xe0 0xdf

No*

Yes

+ F6

Lock

0xe0 0x18 0xe0 0x98

No*

Yes

+ F7

Brightness down

<none>

Yes

Yes

+ F8

Brightness up

<none>

Yes

Yes

+ F9

Media - play/pause

0xe0 0x22 0xe0 0xa2

Yes

No (Gnome)

#33045

+ F10

Media - stop

0xe0 0x24 0xe0 0xa4

Yes

No

#33045

+ F11

Media - skip back

0xe0 0x10 0xe0 0x90

Yes

No

#33045

+ F12

Media - skip forward

0xe0 0x19 0xe0 0x99

Yes

No

#33045

+ 1

Nothing

Yes

*

#33045

+ 2

Nothing

Yes

*

#33045

Other special keys

Key

Operation

Keycode

Works?

Bug #

in Breezy?

in Dapper (current development)?

Wireless Hotkey

Switch Wireless on/off

<none>

Yes

Yes

DVD

Launch DVD app

0xe0 0x72 0xe0 0xf2

No

No

#33045

Audio

Launch Music player

0xe0 0x3c 0xe0 0xbc

Yes

Yes

Notes

12 May: NEW REGRESSION: in latest Dapper (updates to 12th May 2006) the scroll-on-side-of-touchpad feature stopped working! It was working with updates to yesterday (13th May 2006). This is after a hibernate/restart so perhaps related to hibernation.

*External display: Fn-F4 doesn't trigger anything or even attempt to switch displays. There is no keycode output by showkey for this: I guess the BIOS intercepts or something - it's the same for Fn-F7/Fn-F8 which control the brightness, and the wireless on/off key.

*Sleep - Fn-F5 doesn't trigger any action

  • This is marked as working above, please confirm whether it is or not -PaulSladen

  • It's working - sorry, I updated the table above but not the comments here. -JulianRockey

*Lock - Fn-F6 is supposed to lock the machine (I think) but actually it ejects the CD drive instead! Quite handy. On Dapper, it no longer ejects the CD drive, but doesn't do anything at all.

*Fn-1, 2 etc. bring up a small text box on bottom right of Nautilus window if it has focus - not sure what this is.

  • Are they actually supposed to do anything on your laptop? Eg. do they have any small blue/gray writing on them or were they just in the template table and you haven't deleted them? Chances are they are just sending a normal 1 or 2 character which is taken to mean the start of typing a filename into Nautilus -PaulSladen

  • Doh, of course. No they're not supposed to do anything. -JulianRockey

  • Please file these as bugs on Malone against 'acpi-support', along with the keycodes (use 'showkey -s' from a console) or ACPI events 'tail -0f /var/log/acpid' that occur when pressing each of the buttons. -PaulSladen

  • will test in Dapper before filing bugs
    • Did you get a chance to do this? Many Thanks, -PaulSladen

  • Yes, bug #33045 -JulianRockey

*Screen res in Dapper: OK in install (after user selecting available modes during install); wrong in Live

  • Please file a bug against xserver-xorg and it'll be forwarded to the correct place. Please check that the video driver is also getting detected correctly and isn't defaulting to VESA as a fallback -PaulSladen

  • This is working fine now. -JulianRockey

USB mass storage devices work fine.

Video: totem-gstreamer DVD playback is slow and jerky (even with DMA enabled); totem-xine is fine - not sure if this is problem with this laptop's hardware, or totem-gstreamer in general.

  • DMA likely won't make much difference since DVD video is less than 1 Megabyte per second and it's the decoding that takes the time; Any laptop faster than 400Mhz should be able to do it in software fine, let alone with hardware help. If you load xine from the commandline, are there any error or debug messages; if you find any that give an indication, please file a bug against xine -PaulSladen

  • This testing was with GStreamer-0.8. I used Totem-Xine now and it's fine. I've not had a chance to test GStreamer-0.10 but from what I read I suspect this is a general GStreamer issue rather than specific to this laptop as consensus seems to be not as performant as Xine. -JulianRockey

Vodafone 3G card: I have one of these 3G PCMCIA cards and it works on Breezy with a bit of modules config, and on Dapper all that's needed is a pppd script to connect.

Hibernate (suspend to hard disk) option is offered by GDM and hibernate shutdown completed, however on starting ahead freezes after re-loading memory snapshot, and have to power off to and reboot normally. This works fine with SuSE 10.

  • SuSE ship with a different suspend system rather than the one in the kernel, which is the one we need to get working. Can you please file a bug against acpi-support with a report about whether Caps-Lock still works when it's frozen. -PaulSladen

  • The above testing was with Breezy. Sleep works fine on Dapper. Hibernate occasionally has problems as noted above. I will test more and file bug with more info. -JulianRockey

Sleep (suspend to RAM) option not offered from GDM.

  • This need to be whitelisted on a per machine basis. You can enable Suspend in /etc/default/acpi-support (it's the top option). If Suspend on your machine then works, please file a bug against acpi-support along with the dmidecode data used to identify your laptop. -PaulSladen

  • It's working in Dapper (above testing was with Breezy). -JulianRockey

I don't believe there's a friendly way to configure external monitors for laptop in Ubuntu (either xinerama or mirror) and I haven't tried attempting it by editing xorg.conf. The laptop can manage to drive two monitors in 'mirror' config with OpenSuSE 10.

  • Yes, this is a missing feature, I think there maybe a Google SoC 2006 bountie on getting something working. If you get a working config, please file it in this page, or elsewhere so that it can be auto-configured when the right time comes -PaulSladen

  • I'm hoping the Fn-F4 thing might work: am I right in thinking that laptops sometimes support this at the BIOS level so no X config might be needed? -JulianRockey

It's a shame the built-in cardreaders don't work, but I don't think there are any linux drivers around for these things anyway.

  • Above it says that the SD/MMC reader is working, please can you confirm whether this is the case or not, Many Thanks -PaulSladen

  • Neither worked in Breezy. In Dapper it works fine for an SD card, but not MemoryStick. It takes other kinds of card too (MMS I think) but I don't have any to try. -JulianRockey

LaptopTestingTeam/Old/HPDV4000 (last edited 2010-03-02 10:01:37 by host226-241-dynamic)